Elakkan ‘Double Standard’

SOP baharu bagi anggota Kabinet kembali ke tanah air selepas tugas rasmi di luar negara yang diumumkan semalam menjadi perbualan hangat di kalangan rakyat. Peraturan baharu memendekkan tempoh kuarantin khas bagi anggota Kabinet dari 10 hari ke 3 hari.

Apa sahaja penjelasan teknikal yang diberikan, dalam keadaan kesempitan rakyat hari ini, sukar untuk menjustifikasikan keputusan ini dari sudut moral.

Bukan menidakkan pentingnya hubungan diplomasi. Bukan menidakkan pemimpin Kerajaan mungkin ada keperluan ke luar negara bagi tujuan rasmi yang dibuat demi kepentingan negara, walaupun keperluan itu pun boleh dipertikai.

Namun, andai kita berfikiran positif dan menganggap ada sesuatu mustahak yang menuntut lawatan atau pertemuan fizikal di luar negara sekalipun, semua ini tidak memberi sebab untuk peraturan berbeza dengan rakyat, khususnya berhubung kuarantin setelah pulang ke negara.

– Pertama, soal risiko penularan Covid-19, di mana umum mengetahui tempoh inkubasi melebihi 3 hari. Bayangkan kalau ada satu sahaja kes Menteri yang positif setelah keluar negara dan tidak dikuarantin – apa sahaja penjelasan selepas itu tiada gunanya.

– Kedua, jika dikatakan risiko penularan dibendung kerana “travel bubble” sekalipun, pengecualian ini dilihat tidak adil sedangkan rakyat kebanyakan tidak diberi kemudahan ini.

– Ketiga, pemimpin negara lain pun boleh patuh kepada SOP khususnya kuarantin setelah pulang ke negara mereka – kenapa pemimpin Malaysia tak boleh?

Perdana Menteri Australia Scott Morrison melawat Jepun pada Oktober tahun lepas dan setelah tiba kembali ke Australia, beliau menjalani kuarantin mandatori 14 hari sambil menyertai sesi parlimen melalui video.

Dari awal pandemik setahun dahulu, Kerajaan menekankan pentingnya usaha bersama untuk mengatasi cabaran Covid-19.

Maka jika benar ia usaha bersama, seberapa boleh, pemimpin Kerajaan wajar meletakkan diri mereka melalui peraturan sama dengan rakyat yang bersusah dan berkorban jauh lebih besar.

SHAHRIL HAMDAN
Ketua Penerangan UMNO Malaysia

Do away with double standard

THE new SOP for Cabinet members returning from overseas duty as announced yesterday became a hot topic of conversation among the people.  It shortened the quarantine period from 10 days to 3 days.
In current situation, any explanation given will not justify such a move. What’s so special about them?
We are not denying the importance of diplomatic relations. Nor to deny that Government leaders need to go abroad for official purposes in the interest of the country, although that can be disputed too.
However, if we think positively and consider that there is something important that demands a visit or physical meeting abroad, all this does not give a reason for different rules with that of the people, especially regarding quarantine after returning home.
– First, the issue of the risk of Covid-19 transmission, when the public knows the incubation or quarantine period is more than 3 days. Try to imagine having only one positive Minister’s case after leaving the country that doesn’t need any quarantine – any explanation will be useless.
– Secondly, suppose the risk of transmission is curbed due to “travel bubble”, this exception is seen as unfair as most people are not given similar treatment.
– Third, leaders of other countries can also comply with the SOP, especially quarantine after returning to their country – why can’t Malaysian leaders?
Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison visited Japan in October last year and upon his return to Australia, he underwent a mandatory 14-day quarantine while participating in a parliamentary session via video.
From the beginning of the pandemic a year ago, the Government emphasized the importance of joint efforts to overcome the challenges of Covid-19.
In that’s the case, our leaders should be on the same rules as others.
SHAHRIL HAMDAN
UMNO Information Chief